Premiere on Fox — A new study sounds the alarm about female-identifying, biologically male felons incarcerated in female-only prisons, saying the inmates pose physical and psychological risks to biological females. .
“Male prisoners who identify as women are disproportionately likely to commit sex crimes, and incarcerated women face increased risks under these policies,” said a report released Thursday by the nonprofit Independent Women and shared exclusively with Fox News Digital. High risk of harassment and assault.
“Incarcerating transgender men, particularly those with intact male genitalia or a history of violent sexual offending, with female prisoners could severely disenfranchise women,” the report states. “These risks – and the impact on women and men who suffer The consequences of mixed prison settings for women—already manifesting themselves—are well known, yet these risks are deliberately ignored in deference to laws and policies that marginalize incarcerated women and quell concerns about their safety.
Amie Ichikawa was sentenced to five years in prison for making terrorist threats with a firearm. After she was released from prison, she began to advocate for female prisoners who were worried about being locked up with their biological men.
California women’s prisons now welcome biological men: ‘Agenda to eliminate women’
Amie Ichikawa was sentenced to five years in prison for making terrorist threats with a firearm. After she was released from prison, she began to advocate for female prisoners who were worried about being locked up with their biological men. (independent woman)
“This is because the law is based on self-identification. The only requirement is that someone declares that they are a woman,” Ichikawa told Fox News Digital. “You can’t deny based on physical characteristics, including retaining a penis. You can’t deny someone a transfer based on a criminal record.”
Male inmates who identify as female often have cases before review boards and argue that sex-based prisons violate equal protection laws or claim they have been discriminated against on the basis of sex.
Transgender, biologically male inmates also will argue that the conditions they are housed in men’s prisons violate the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment, Independent Woman reports.
Nearly 75% of trans prisoners in UK jailed for rape and brutal crimes
In four states, biologically male inmates who identify as female can be housed in women-only prisons.
Countries that allow transgender prisoners to be housed based on their gender identity. (independent woman)
These states include California, Connecticut, Maine and New Jersey. Two states, Utah and Louisiana, prohibit sending men to women’s prisons, while all other states operate on a case-by-case basis.
According to the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP), as of October 2024, there were 1,487 incarcerated men in federal prisons who identified themselves as women, and only some of them were incarcerated in women’s prisons.
Women’s rights ‘forgotten’ for trans prisoners, ex-prisoners speak out in new documentary
People wave transgender pride flags during the 2023 Los Angeles Pride Parade on June 11, 2023 in Hollywood, California. (Robin Baker/AFP via Getty Images)
According to BOP statistics cited in the Independent Woman report, nearly half of transgender male prisoners are sexually offenders, compared with less than 12% of the national male prison population.
“Women should not be locked up in locked prisons with male violent criminals,” said May Mailman, legal director of the Independent Women’s Organization. “Period [2024 presidential] On the campaign trail, Kamala Harris has unashamedly publicly supported trans men in women’s prisons and tried to show that the law requires this madness.
“She’s wrong. Cruel and Unusual Punishment: Stopping the Dangerous Policy of Putting Men in Women’s Prisons makes clear that policy leaders have clear authority to protect women and preserve sanity. For politicians trying to end this phenomenon This is a must-read for anyone who works with you.
Trans policy advocates say placing female inmates in women-only prisons would allow them to live in a safer environment, as transgender women face sexual abuse in men-only prisons.
“Jails and prisons often subject transgender people in their care to abuse, including denial of medical care, long periods of solitary confinement, and harassment, sexual assault, and violence by guards and others with whom they are held,” the Transgender Law Center stated in its stated on the website. “Recent research shows that trans women are 13 times more likely to be sexually assaulted in prison than other women.”
But female prisoners also face sexual abuse by transgender prisoners who are biologically male, and they feel their concerns are not being addressed.
Female prisoner Dana Gray told Independent Women that she was sexually assaulted in January 2023 by a “physically intact” trans woman.
Female prisoner Dana Gray told Independent Women that she was sexually assaulted in January 2023 by a “physically intact” trans woman. (independent woman)
“It was scary and disgusting because I knew there was nothing I could do,” Gray said.
“This is the perfect Trojan horse to tap into the largest pool of victims anyone could hope and dream for.”
“The transgender community has been hijacked as a safe haven for severely mentally ill sex offenders,” Ichikawa said. “This is the perfect Trojan horse into the largest victim pool anyone could hope and dream for. [are] I’ve talked to trans women in men’s prisons who want nothing to do with it and are appalled that state and federal agencies allow people to be transferred [to female prisons]”.
Additionally, those who oppose housing transgender prisoners in women-only prisons have also led to traumatic incidents for some women.
California female inmates file lawsuit saying prison sex abuse didn’t stop despite previous indictments against officers
Child sex trafficking survivor Alyssa Kamholz had to share a cell with a female man who belonged to the same gang as her childhood abuser, reports say.
Child sex trafficking survivor Alyssa Kamholz had to share a cell with a female man who belonged to the same gang as her childhood abuser, reports say. (played by Alyssa Camholtz)
Ichikawa believed that some men who identified themselves as women would manipulate the system and be sent to women’s prisons to gain more power than men’s prisons.
The topic of housing transgender inmates in women’s prisons has sparked lawsuits and shocking headlines across the country.
Man impersonated transgender female inmate at Rikers Island last year Rape a female prisoneraccording to a lawsuit filed by the victim. Additionally, last year, Tremaine Deon Carroll, a California inmate who is biologically male and identifies as female, was charged with two counts of forcible rape, according to the Central California Women’s Prison and one count of “dissuading a witness from testifying.” Website gets 4W for the first time Later reported by Reduxx.
California corrections officer fired for sexually abusing inmates at federal women’s prison
Tremaine “Tremayne” Deon Carroll, 52, a violent offender incarcerated in California, was charged with rape in Madera County. Carroll, who is transgender, was held in a women’s prison at request and was transferred to a men’s prison after being accused of rape. (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention)
Demi Minor is a transgender inmate in New Jersey; Pregnant two female prisoners 2022. An Indiana judge ruled last year that biological men convicted of killing infants, who are women, can receive state funding. gender reassignment surgery.
Hannah Tubbs, a California transgender inmate who was 17 at the time, was convicted of molesting a young girl in Denny’s bathroom in 2017. George Gascon’s rule for suspects under the age of 18, Tubbs was 26 when the case was finally heard. In a girls’ juvenile correctional facility Because the crime was committed just days before Tubbs’ 18th birthday.
Hannah Tubbs began self-identifying as a woman in 2014 after being arrested in a child molestation case in Los Angeles County. (Los Angeles County)
Before he could complete his sentence, however, Tubbs, 27, was charged in Kern County with first-degree murder, witness intimidation, robbery and assault. Tubbs pleaded guilty to manslaughter and lesser charges in exchange for 15 years in prison November 2023.
Click here to get the Fox News app
The IWF’s new documentary series Cruel and Unusual Punishment: Men Taking Over Women’s Prisons shares stories of abuse and retaliation as they raise concerns about the issue.
The IWF report calls for solutions, including amending the Prison Rape Elimination Act to “prevent transfers to women’s prisons based on gender identity” and clarifying that the Americans with Disabilities Act “does not mandate ‘transitional’ services or co-ed housing” .
