Drew Dietsch Published
How do you pick the worst Star Wars movie? There are many criteria by which to judge. Will you choose the one you find most boring? How about the one with the silliest plot? Maybe you should pick the one that effectively killed the film franchise for over five years?
These are all valid criteria for judging the worst Star Wars movie, but we have to look at this decision from a broader and deeper perspective. There are a lot of superficial reasons to call the Star Wars movies the worst. While some are misunderstood, others are scorned. yes StarCraft V: The Final Frontier A ridiculous vanity project with a climax worthy of ridicule? perhaps. yes StarCraft: Nemesis A weak and unusual send-off. new generation Everyone? certainly.
But these criticisms alone aren’t enough to earn them the title of worst Star Wars movie. Reaching that status requires a story that cuts to the heart of Star Wars’ optimism and hope. It had to be incredibly stupid in the plot department, conceptually lazy and a little profane, and secretly insulting to everything Star Trek was supposed to stand for.
So there’s only one option left for the worst Star Wars movie: StarCraft: Into Darkness.
The worst Star Wars movie looks like
There are many deeper reasons StarCraft: Into Darkness Arguably the worst Star Wars movie, but before we really get into that, let’s take a look at the film’s more immediate problems and mistakes.
The most pressing question is StarCraft: Into Darkness want to start from StarCraft II: Wrath of Khanarguably the fan-favorite entry in the entire series. When a film remakes or reconfigures elements of a previously popular film, it’s not inherently a bad thing, but the way StarCraft: Into Darkness deal with it Wrath of Khan The parts are awkward.
Benedict Cumberbatch’s performance is somehow both grandiose and understated, never reaching the dramatic joy of Ricardo Montalban’s iconic take on the character. Most horrifying is the tone-deaf remix of the haunting “Khan!” Zachary Quinto immediately screamed and just…*sigh*.
It is worth mentioning that the cast StarCraft: Into Darkness Doing their best to write a truly outrageous script. J.J. Abrams struck gold when he cast the show for the 2009 reboot, but a great cast couldn’t save a story filled with characters with bad motivations, and if you think about it, the story The jumps in narrative logic are untenable, as well as an overall tone that is constantly contradictory.
title StarCraft: Into Darkness There’s definitely a sense of, “Oh, this Star Wars movie is going to be a serious thing!” That’s definitely what the movie wants you to believe, but it goes from straight-faced grim to silly The characters’ wild transformations are so intensely conflicting and rupture as they collide with each other. The film never quite finds its tonal beat.
Related:
‘Star Wars: Deep Space Nine” Conversations That Changed TV History
Part of the reason is because StarCraft: Into Darkness It’s a mess in terms of filmmaking.
Chaos behind the camera
When J.J. Abrams took over the long-running series in 2009 StarCraftwho infused the series with a special sense of manic action energy. To be fair, new generation The movies do establish that tone-wise, but their filmmaking style remains relatively grounded. A large part of this is because pure digital photography has not yet advanced to the point where it can render believable landscapes and fluid camera movements.
However, this capability has been around since 2009 StarCraft Rolling around, Abrams took full advantage. Driven by this aesthetic and energetic choice, he turned it up to 11. StarCraft: Into Darkness This is unbearable. It’s an onslaught of noise and visual chaos that no longer serves a storytelling function.
However, this filmmaking choice wasn’t as annoying in the ’09 film, as it felt in sync with that film’s swashbuckling tone. StarCraft: Into Darkness“The decision to try to go bleak while maintaining the visual language of a more thrilling adventure story heightened this dissonance.
Still, all of these issues and others—poor villain handling, poor characterization, questionable depictions of female characters—pale in comparison to the elements that truly make it relatable. StarCraft: Into Darkness The worst Star Wars movie ever.
The Insidiousness of Star Wars: Into Darkness
When we talk about the worst Star Wars movie ever made, we have to consider more than just the performance of the film itself. StarCraft: Into Darkness As a sci-fi action movie, it fails, but what makes it downright disgusting is its relationship to the history of Star Trek as a vision and ideal.
Screenwriter Roberto Orci was able to use StarCraft: Into Darkness as an allegorical vehicle for his own unsavory conspiracy theories about the 9/11 attacks. It may sound ridiculous, but the homage to “post-9/11 veterans” at the end of the film reinvigorates the entire film.
The details you read about in the film are well documented elsewhere, so I won’t repeat all of these observations. Instead, I want to highlight why this particular aspect is truly StarCraft: Into Darkness The worst Star Wars movie ever.
As a fictional concept, Star Wars is intended to represent humanity’s most optimistic possibilities. Yes, there are some key episodes throughout the series that test the integrity of Star Wars’ ideals – including one of the best episodes of Star Wars ever. deep space nine — but it always comes from a sincerity and sincerity to the world that Star Wars is trying to build.
StarCraft: Into Darkness That hope is removed and replaced with shameless cynicism. It denigrates Starfleet and the Federation, portraying them as an inherently corrupt organization whose leaders want to foment war at all costs. It rips out the core of Star Wars and replaces it with something so rotten that it’s impossible to watch this movie without feeling sick.
That’s not to say that the world of Star Wars can’t handle self-critical and dark stories. deep space nine is my favorite StarCraft series, not least because of its willingness to pay homage to the ideals and practices of the Federation and Starfleet. However, the creators behind deep space nine It’s clear that the key creatives behind it have a deep, understanding love for StarCraft StarCraft: Into Darkness Don’t share. Instead, they use Star Wars to sell a misanthropic worldview that is ugly on its own but becomes even uglier when spread through the world of Star Wars.
It’s clear that it’s this creativity that leads to this horrific situation. sequel, StarCraft III: Beyond the Starschanged directors and screenwriters, resulting in the best of the reboot movies. That movie was even able to offer some criticism of the Confederacy without resorting to a sinister political agenda.
This is a big reason StarCraft: Into Darkness Has to be the worst Star Wars movie ever. You can argue the fictional and technical merits of all the other films, but none come close to positively representing something so toxic at its core. If you like Star Wars, you’ll probably like its take on humanity and its belief that we can work together for the greater good. If you love StarCraft, you’ll love Hope. StarCraft: Into Darkness It’s a desperate, vindictive, unethical stain on the name StarCraft.
If that doesn’t make it the worst Star Wars movie, I don’t know what will. I think God needs a starship at any time.
